Our songbirds are in problem in part because of habitat loss. This issue is intensified by another danger– brood parasitism by the brown-headed cowbird (Molothrus ater).
Due to the fact that they dont develop nests, nurture eggs, or feed chicks, cowbirds conserve their energy and are able to produce as much as an egg each day each nesting season. Its an interesting strategy for survival, but the host birds– consisting of the endangered vireo– pay the cost of raising the cowbird young.
Cowbirds are belonging to the Great Plains of North America, however after the last glacial epoch, they didnt begin making their method into California till about 120 years ago. It is thought that some species are for that reason less well-adapted to deal with brood parasitism.
The vireo is one of them.
The least Bells vireo is a threatened subspecies. © Robin Gwen Agarwal/ Flickr
Catching Cowbirds to Save Vireos
The vireo may be thought about a conservation-reliant species in some locations– that means that in order to endure, it requires direct human support in the form of cowbird control. Minimizing the effect of cowbirds has been a major focus of preservation management for the vireo.
By trapping and removing cowbirds, supervisors can considerably reduce or perhaps get rid of cowbird parasitism of vireo nests. As an outcome, mitigation funds for the disruption or destruction of vireo environment have in lots of cases been directed into cowbird trapping.
The Nature Conservancy has routinely used trapping to manage cowbirds and support the recovery of the vireo and other songbird species. Numerous years ago, I provided the results of our trapping program on the Santa Clara River in southern California at a Partners in Flight conference– we had actually been trapping for 25 years at that point, were running 20 traps during the nesting season, and had actually caught and eliminated 239 cowbirds that year. I was approached later by two ornithologists.
” We believe you are trapping excessive,” they informed me.
As it ends up, cowbird traps are not a silver bullet.
Cowbirds lay their eggs in the nests of other birds. Here, four brown-headed cowbird eggs (speckled) rest along with dickcissel eggs (blue). © Chris Helzer/ TNC
They catch more than just cowbirds. On the Santa Clara River, California towhees (Melozone crissalis), yellow-headed blackbirds (Xanthocephalus xanthocephalus), and red-winged blackbirds (Agelaius phoeniceus) are just a few of the non-target types that are typically discovered in cowbird traps.
While they typically survive the trapping experience itself, their time in the trap is time they cant invest in other important activities such as foraging and nurturing eggs. So, the traps might be damaging species other than just cowbirds.
Second, it is pricey to operate cowbird traps. Some argue that we invest excessive preservation financing on cowbird trapping, and not enough on safeguarding and bring back the environment that vireos requirement.
While funding for these activities might not be interchangeable, it is essential to consider what other ways of cowbird management might benefit songbirds like the vireo, while lessening expenses and harm to other species.
California towhees are in some cases caught in cowbird traps. © Becky Matsubara/ Flickr
Adaptive Management
In 2015, we formed a cowbird working group on the Santa Clara River to do just that. We carried out a multi-year experiment to test 3 various cowbird management techniques, while keeping track of nest parasitism to see how these modifications impacted vireos. First, we tried using webs to capture individual cowbirds. Second, we attempted running the cowbird traps continually, however over a shorter trapping season. Third, we attempted to catch specific individual cowbirds by releasing a trap for a really brief period.
The outcomes of our research study have just been published in the Journal of Wildlife Management.
Nets did not work to catch cowbirds at our website, maybe because the plant life, and therefore the cowbirds and songbirds, was topped a location of numerous hundred acres. In contrast, we discovered that when operating traps continuously, we could shorten the trapping season by a month and still eliminate brood parasitism of vireo nests.
Related Articles
We likewise discovered that very short-duration trapping worked well to record specific cowbirds. Integrated with tracking of both cowbirds and vireo nests in the field, extremely short duration trapping is an alternative that can permit supervisors to stop operating traps continually, and significantly lower the number of non-target individuals captured in traps.
Furthermore, there was substantial cost conserving related to utilizing the very brief duration trapping method vs. the continuous trapping technique.
The result is that the cowbird trap remains an important tool for managers to benefit threatened songbirds. It is one that ought to be utilized in a sparing and targeted style, both to avoid hurting other types, and to make the best usage of conservation funds. Over-trapping is a costly trap for supervisors to avoid.
Songbirds remain in difficulty. My house county of Los Angeles has been called the birdiest in the United States, yet songbirds like the least Bells vireo (Vireo bellii pusillus) are endangered here. Its not a surprise.
Migratory songbird species like the vireo spend the winter season in Latin America, and after that fly north in the spring to breed in the plant life that grows along our streams and rivers. Waterways, and the vegetation growing adjacent to them, are naturally unusual in Southern California.
Human beings have even more minimized the extent of these riverside environments through agricultural activities and urbanization, the structure of dams, river channelization, and the clearing of plant life.
As a result, staying habitat spots ideal for nesting songbirds are small and support far fewer people than they once did.
The Nature Conservancy has actually regularly utilized trapping to control cowbirds and support the healing of the vireo and other songbird types. Numerous years ago, I presented the results of our trapping program on the Santa Clara River in southern California at a Partners in Flight conference– we had been trapping for 25 years at that point, were running 20 traps during the nesting season, and had captured and gotten rid of 239 cowbirds that year. We performed a multi-year experiment to check 3 various cowbird management strategies, while keeping track of nest parasitism to see how these changes impacted vireos. Second, we tried operating the cowbird traps continuously, but over a shorter trapping season. The upshot is that the cowbird trap stays an important tool for managers to benefit threatened songbirds.
The Paper
