“Whatcheeria is more carefully associated to living tetrapods like reptiles and amphibians and mammals than it is to anything else, but it falls outside of those contemporary groups,” states Ken Angielczyk, a manager at the Field Museum and co-author of the research study. Considering that the Field has so lots of Whatcheeria specimens, researchers are able to use them to study the animal at various stages of its life. With so many people at the Field, researchers have actually been able to identify variation within the types: some Whatcheeria are 6 and a half feet long, while others are much smaller sized. To see how Whatcheeria grew, Otoo and Angielczyk provided up thigh bones from nine Whatcheeria individuals ranging from juvenile to adult. In taking a look at the bone pieces, Whitney found proof that Whatcheeria grew rapidly when it was young, and then leveled off over time.
A Whatcheeria skull in the collections of the Field Museum, with its numerous sharp teeth visible. Credit: Kate Golembiewski, Field Museum
” If you saw Whatcheeria in life, it would most likely appear like a big crocodile-shaped salamander, with a narrow head and great deals of teeth,” states Ben Otoo, a co-author of the research study and a PhD student at the University of Chicago and the Field Museum. “If it actually huddled, probably to an uneasy level, it might fit in your tub, however neither you nor it would desire it to be there.”.
Thats due to the fact that Whatcheeria was a top predator. “It most likely would have invested a lot of time near the bottoms of rivers and lakes, lunging out and eating whatever it liked,” says Otoo.
Co-author Ben Otoo standing by a life-size illustration of a big Whatcheeria specimen at the Field Museum. Credit: Courtesy of Ben Otoo.
While Whatcheeria appears like a huge salamander, it isnt one– its a “stem tetrapod,” an early four-legged critter thats part of the lineage that eventually evolved into the four-limbed animals alive today. “Whatcheeria is more carefully related to living tetrapods like reptiles and amphibians and mammals than it is to anything else, however it falls beyond those modern-day groups,” states Ken Angielczyk, a curator at the Field Museum and co-author of the study. “That suggests that it can help us find out about how tetrapods, including us, developed.”.
Because the Field has so lots of Whatcheeria specimens, scientists are able to utilize them to study the animal at different stages of its life. With so lots of people at the Field, researchers have actually been able to identify variation within the species: some Whatcheeria are six and a half feet long, while others are much smaller sized.
Co-author Ken Angielczyk with a drawer of Whatcheeria specimens behind the scenes at the Field Museum. Credit: Kate Golembiewski, Field Museum.
” Examining these fossils is like checking out a storybook, and we are attempting to check out as numerous chapters as possible by taking a look at how juveniles grow developing up to adulthood,” stated Megan Whitney, the research studys lead author, a teacher at Loyola University in Chicago who began dealing with the project at Harvard University. “Because of where Whatcheeria sits in the early tetrapod ancestral tree, we wished to target this animal and look at its storybook at different stages of life.”.
A few of the many drawers consisting of Whatcheeria specimens and other fossils from the Iowan quarry where the animal was discovered. Credit: Kate Golembiewski, Field Museum.
To see how Whatcheeria grew, Otoo and Angielczyk provided thigh bones from nine Whatcheeria people ranging from juvenile to adult. Whitney and her advisor, Harvard Universitys Stephanie Pierce, took thin pieces of bone and analyzed them under a microscopic lense. When an animal is growing, it develops new layers of bone every growing season, says Otoo. “You may see a seasonal pattern where the animal is growing a lot during the spring and summertime and then stopping in winter and resuming the next spring,” they explain. “By taking a look at how thick the growth rings are over the course of an animals life, you can determine if the animals growing constantly throughout its life time, maybe with some momentary disturbances, or essentially growing to an adult size, then stopping.”.
In contemporary tetrapods, some animals grow a lot as juveniles and then stop when they reach their adult years– birds and mammals, including us, are like that. In analyzing the bone pieces, Whitney found evidence that Whatcheeria grew quickly when it was young, and then leveled off over time.
” I have a really unique memory of jumping on Slack with Stephanie Pierce and saying, this breaks all of the rules that we thought about for how growth is evolving in these early tetrapods,” stated Whitney.
The discovery assists illuminate what some aspects of Whatcheerias life resembled. “If youre going to be a top predator, a large animal, it can be a competitive benefit to get huge quickly as it makes it much easier to hunt other animals, and harder for other predators to hunt you,” stated Pierce. “It can likewise be a helpful survival method when residing in unpredictable environments, such as the lake system Whatcheeria populated, which went through seasonal passing away periods.”.
Theres a compromise: growing actually huge really fast takes a huge amount of energy, which can be an issue if theres not adequate food and resources for the growing animal. Its easier to get simply enough food to get a little bit bigger, the very same method its simpler to make smaller regular monthly rental payments than it is to save up for a huge downpayment on a house.
In addition to assisting offer us a better sense of the evolutionary pressures on early tetrapods, scientists state the findings are a reminder that evolution isnt a cool stepwise process: its a series of experiments.
” Evolution is about attempting out different way of lives and mixes of functions,” states Angielczyk. “And so you get an animal like Whatcheeria thats an early tetrapod, but its also a quite fast-growing one.
Recommendation: “Fossil bone histology exposes ancient origins for rapid juvenile growth in tetrapods” by Megan R. Whitney, Benjamin K. A. Otoo, Kenneth D. Angielczyk and Stephanie E. Pierce, 28 November 2022, Communications Biology.DOI: 10.1038/ s42003-022-04079-0.
Whatcheeria was an ancient superpredator. It was a six-foot-long lake-dwelling creature with a salamander-like body and a long, narrow head. Credit: Adrienne Stroup, Field Museum
Ancient Iowan superpredator got big by front-loading its growth in its youth.
Fossils found only at the Field Museum expose the development history of Whatcheeria.
The Field Museum in Chicago is well-known for SUE the T. rex, it is likewise house to the best, most-complete fossils of a prehistoric superpredator– one that lived hundreds of millions of years before Tyrannosaurs wandered the Earth. Whatcheeria was a six-foot-long lake-dwelling animal with a salamander-like body and a long, narrow head. Its strange name comes from the reality that its fossils were found in a limestone quarry near the town of What Cheer, Iowa.
There are around 350 Whatcheeria specimens, ranging from single bones to finish skeletons, that have actually been discovered, and every last one of them resides in the Field Museums collections. In a brand-new study released on November 28 in the journal Communications Biology, these specimens helped expose how Whatcheeria grew huge enough to hazard its fishy victim: it grew quickly in its youth, instead of growing “slow and consistent” the manner in which numerous contemporary reptiles and amphibians do.
