December 23, 2024

Critical Oversight in EPA’s PFAS Rules: Ignoring a Key Contaminant Source

By Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences
June 3, 2023

Permanently chemicals, scientifically known as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), are a group of relentless pollutants that position significant ecological and health threats. PFAS compounds come in 2 types: a precursor form and a terminal kind. Much of the PFAS at military websites consists of precursors that are left out from standard analytical techniques. The research study finds that contamination of two of the newly managed PFAS chemicals (perfluorohexane sulfonate: PFHxS and perfluorbutane sulfonate: PFBS) at one military base on Cape Cod, Massachusetts are sustained by microbial precursor biotransformation in the soil. The researchers projected utilizing a computer system design and field information that, without removal, prevalent PFAS contamination of drinking water supplies near military centers is likely to persist for centuries.

PFAS substances can be found in two types: a precursor type and a terminal kind. Most of the monitored PFAS substances are terminal compounds. The EPAs draft drinking water guidelines are for six terminal substances that do not deteriorate under regular environmental conditions. Precursor compounds can be transformed through biological or environmental procedures into terminal kinds. There are numerous precursor substances, the majority of which are not regularly monitored, and none are currently managed.
The U.S. military is the largest worldwide user of fire-retardant foams consisting of PFAS known as AFFF (liquid movie forming foam). For years, hundreds of military bases throughout the U.S. and worldwide used AFFF including high levels of PFAS for fire training drills and fighting fires. AFFF usage is one of the biggest sources of PFAS contamination in drinking water.
” Many PFAS precursors present in AFFF are hard to measure. This work shows that they are gradually changing into PFAS of health concern at AFFF-contaminated sites and adding to downstream contamination” said Elsie Sunderland, Fred Kavli Professor of Environmental Chemistry and Professor of Earth and Planetary Sciences at SEAS and senior author on the brand-new paper.
Much of the PFAS at military sites consists of precursors that are left out from standard analytical methods. The study discovers that contamination of two of the newly regulated PFAS chemicals (perfluorohexane sulfonate: PFHxS and perfluorbutane sulfonate: PFBS) at one military base on Cape Cod, Massachusetts are sustained by microbial precursor biotransformation in the soil.
The scientists predicted utilizing a computer system model and field information that, without removal, widespread PFAS contamination of drinking water products near military facilities is likely to continue for centuries. Regardless of contamination of nearby aquifers that may already position a risk to human health, most of PFAS are still being in the soils surrounding these infected sites, emphasizing the immediate requirement for advances in remediation innovation that are reliable at cleaning up both precursor and terminal substances. Considering that regulations focus just on terminal substances, the effectiveness of existing removal technologies at cleaning up precursors is not known.
The scientists concluded that raised PFAS exposures downstream of more than 300 U.S. military centers that used the fire-fighting foams might similarly continue for centuries.
” The role of PFAS precursors in sustaining harmful levels of contamination at Joint Base Cape Cod raises issue about whether exposure dangers are underestimated near hundreds of other sites where they are not measured,” stated Bridger Ruyle, the first author of the research study and previous doctoral trainee in Sunderlands Lab.
The general public remark period for EPAs draft PFAS drinking water guideline closes on May 30. While an action in the right direction, there are countless PFAS chemical structures, a number of numerous which have currently been detected in the environment, Sunderland notes.
In related work also released in Environmental Science & & Technology, Sunderlands group likewise has shown that the variety of military fire training areas within a watershed is a great predictor for PFAS contamination in a communitys drinking water system. Some groups are at greater risk than others; a forthcoming publication by the Sunderland laboratory documents marked sociodemographic variations in direct exposures to PFAS and proximity to PFAS sources throughout the country.
Recommendations: “Centurial Persistence of Forever Chemicals at Military Fire Training Sites” by Bridger J. Ruyle, Colin P. Thackray, Craig M. Butt, Denis R. LeBlanc, Andrea K. Tokranov, Chad D. Vecitis and Elsie M. Sunderland, 15 May 2023, Environmental Science & & Technology.DOI: 10.1021/ acs.est.3 c00675.
” Sociodemographic Factors Are Associated with the Abundance of PFAS Sources and Detection in U.S. Community Water Systems” by Jahred M. Liddie, Laurel A. Schaider, and Elsie M. Sunderland, 15 May 2023, Environmental Science & & Technology.DOI: 10.1021/ acs.est.2 c07255.
The study was funded by the Department of Defense Strategic Environmental Research and Development Program and the U.S. National Institute for Environmental Health Sciences Superfund Research Program. Extra assistance was provided by the U.S. Geological Survey Toxic Substances Hydrology Program.

Permanently chemicals, scientifically understood as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), are a group of persistent toxins that posture considerable ecological and health threats. These chemicals are called “permanently” because they do not break down naturally and can continue in the environment for centuries. Their widespread usage in numerous industries, combined with their persistence and possible toxicity, has actually raised serious concerns about their long-term effect on ecosystems and human health.
A current research study carried out by Harvard discovered that unmonitored PFAS can build up and last for centuries.
Previously in the year, the United States Environmental Protection Agency proposed the maximum allowed levels of six PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances), also called “forever chemicals,” in potable water. These provisional regulations do not cover half of the PFAS discovered at pollution websites across the country.
This info was discovered by a group led by the Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS). Their findings were recently released in the journal Environmental Science & & Technology
. PFAS are present in fire retardant foams to name a few products and have been developing in the environment considering that they were very first created by Dupont in the 1930s and made commonly by 3M starting in the 1950s. Exposures to some PFAS are linked to a range of health threats consisting of cancer, immune suppression, diabetes, and low baby birth weight.