November 22, 2024

“Havana Syndrome” Mystery Deepens As NIH Finds No Evidence of Brain Injury

“While we did not identify significant differences in participants with AHIs, its essential to acknowledge that these symptoms are extremely real, trigger substantial disturbance in the lives of those affected and can be quite extended, disabling, and hard to deal with. Researchers also utilized deep phenotyping, which is an analysis of observable characteristics or biochemical attributes of a specific, to assess any connections between scientifically reported symptoms and neuroimaging findings.For the imaging portion of the study, participants went through MRI scans an average of 80 days following symptom onset, although some individuals had an MRI as quickly as 14 days after reporting an AHI. Utilizing thorough and robust method, which resulted in extremely reproducible MRI metrics, the scientists were unable to identify a constant set of imaging problems that might distinguish participants with AHIs from neurological factors to consider and controls.clinical results” An absence of evidence for an MRI-detectable distinction in between people with Controls and ahis does not exclude that a negative event impacting the brain happened at the time of the AHI,” stated Carlo Pierpaoli, M.D., Ph.D., senior investigator and chief of the Laboratory on Quantitative Medical Imaging at the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering, part of NIH, and lead author on the neuroimaging paper. Compared to controls, individuals with AHIs self-reported considerably increased symptoms of fatigue, post-traumatic tension and depression.Forty-one percent of individuals in the AHI group, from nearly every geographical location, met the requirements for functional neurological disorders (FNDs), a group of typical neurological motion disorders caused by an abnormality in how the brain functions, or had considerable somatic symptoms.

NIH researchers carried out a comprehensive study on people experiencing anomalous health incidents, understood as Havana Syndrome, and discovered no significant MRI-detected brain injuries or scientific differences compared to controls. Regardless of substantial testing, the symptoms, which include cognitive dysfunction and lightheadedness, were not connected to noticeable neurological damage however were acknowledged as authentic and impactful. Compared to healthy volunteers, impacted U.S. government personnel did not show MRI-detectable brain injury or biological irregularities that would explain symptoms.Using innovative imaging techniques and in-depth clinical evaluations, a research team at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) discovered no considerable evidence of MRI-detectable brain injury, nor differences in a lot of scientific steps compared to controls, among a group of federal workers who experienced anomalous health incidents (AHIs). These incidents, including hearing noise and experiencing head pressure followed by headache, dizziness, cognitive dysfunction, and other symptoms, have actually been described in the news media as “Havana Syndrome” considering that U.S. federal government personnel stationed in Havana first reported the occurrences. Researchers at the NIH Clinical Center conducted the research study over the course of nearly 5 years and published their findings on March 18 in 2 documents in JAMA.” Our objective was to carry out thorough, unbiased, and reproducible assessments to see if we could determine structural brain or biological distinctions in people who reported AHIs,” said Leighton Chan, M.D., chief, rehab medicine and acting chief scientific officer, NIH Clinical Center, and lead author on among the papers. “While we did not identify significant differences in individuals with AHIs, its essential to acknowledge that these symptoms are extremely genuine, cause considerable disruption in the lives of those affected and can be rather extended, disabling, and challenging to deal with.” Research Findings and Clinical AssessmentsResearchers developed multiple techniques to examine more than 80 U.S. civil servant and their adult relative, mostly stationed abroad, who had reported an AHI and compared them to matched healthy controls. The control groups consisted of healthy volunteers who had comparable work projects but did not report AHIs. In this study, individuals underwent a battery of clinical, acoustic, balance, visual, neuropsychological, and blood biomarkers testing. In addition, they got different kinds of MRI scans targeted at examining volume, structure, and function of the brain.In this study, researchers obtained several measurements and used a number of techniques and models to evaluate the data. This was done to ensure the findings were highly reproducible, indicating similar outcomes were found regardless of the number of times individuals were evaluated or their information statistically evaluated. Researchers also utilized deep phenotyping, which is an analysis of observable characteristics or biochemical characteristics of an individual, to examine any correlations in between medically reported signs and neuroimaging findings.For the imaging part of the research study, participants underwent MRI scans an average of 80 days following symptom start, although some participants had an MRI as quickly as 14 days after reporting an AHI. Using robust and extensive method, which resulted in highly reproducible MRI metrics, the researchers were not able to recognize a constant set of imaging abnormalities that might differentiate individuals with AHIs from neurological factors to consider and controls.clinical results” An absence of evidence for an MRI-detectable difference in between individuals with Controls and ahis does not leave out that an unfavorable event impacting the brain occurred at the time of the AHI,” said Carlo Pierpaoli, M.D., Ph.D., senior private investigator and chief of the Laboratory on Quantitative Medical Imaging at the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering, part of NIH, and lead author on the neuroimaging paper.” It is possible that individuals with an AHI might be experiencing the outcomes of an event that caused their signs, but the injury did not produce the long-term neuroimaging changes that are typically observed after extreme trauma or stroke. We hope these outcomes will reduce concerns about AHI being connected with severe neurodegenerative modifications in the brain.” Similarly, there were no substantial distinctions between individuals reporting AHIs and matched controls with regard to a lot of scientific, research, and biomarker steps, except for certain self-reported procedures. Compared to controls, individuals with AHIs self-reported significantly increased signs of fatigue, post-traumatic tension and depression.Forty-one percent of individuals in the AHI group, from almost every geographical area, fulfilled the criteria for functional neurological disorders (FNDs), a group of common neurological movement conditions brought on by an irregularity in how the brain functions, or had substantial somatic signs. FNDs can be related to depression and anxiety, and high stress.Most of the AHI group with FND fulfilled specific criteria to enable the diagnosis of persistent postural-perceptual dizziness, also referred to as PPPD. Signs of PPPD include dizziness, non-spinning vertigo and fluctuating unsteadiness provoked by social or environmental stimuli that can not be described by some other neurologic condition.” The post-traumatic tension and state of mind signs reported are not unexpected given the ongoing concerns of numerous of the participants,” said Louis French, Psy.D., neuropsychologist and deputy director of the National Intrepid Center of Excellence at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center and a co-investigator on the study. “Often these people have actually had significant disturbance to their lives and continue to have concerns about their health and their future. This level of tension can have substantial negative effect on the recovery process.” The scientists keep in mind that if the symptoms were triggered by some external phenomenon, they lack noticeable or persistent patho-physiologic changes. In addition, it is possible that the physiologic markers of an external phenomenon are no longer noticeable or can not be determined with the existing methods and sample size.References:” Neuroimaging Findings in US Government Personnel and Their Family Members Involved in Anomalous Health Incidents” by Carlo Pierpaoli, Amritha Nayak, Rakibul Hafiz, M. Okan Irfanoglu, Gang Chen, Paul Taylor, Mark Hallett, Michael Hoa, Dzung Pham, Yi-Yu Chou, Anita D. Moses, André J. van der Merwe, Sara M. Lippa, Carmen C. Brewer, Chris K. Zalewski, Cris Zampieri, L. Christine Turtzo, Pashtun Shahim, Leighton Chan, NIH AHI Intramural Research Program Team, Brian Moore, Lauren Stamps, Spencer Flynn, Julia Fontana, Swathi Tata, Jessica Lo, Mirella A. Fernandez, Annie Lori-Joseph, Jesse Matsubara, Julie Goldberg, Thuy-Tien D. Nguyen, Noa Sasson, Justine Lely, Bryan Smith, Kelly A. King, Jennifer Chisholm, Julie Christensen, M. Teresa Magone, Chantal Cousineau-Krieger, Louis M. French, Simge Yonter, Sanaz Attaripour and Chen Lai, 18 March 2024, JAMA.DOI: 10.1001/ jama.2024.2424″ Clinical, Biomarker, and Research Tests Among US Government Personnel and Their Family Members Involved in Anomalous Health Incidents” by Leighton Chan, Mark Hallett, Chris K. Zalewski, Carmen C. Brewer, Cris Zampieri, Michael Hoa, Sara M. Lippa, Edmond Fitzgibbon, Louis M. French, Anita D. Moses, André J. van der Merwe, Carlo Pierpaoli, L. Christine Turtzo, Simge Yonter, Pashtun Shahim, NIH AHI Intramural Research Program Team, Brian Moore, Lauren Stamps, Spencer Flynn, Julia Fontana, Swathi Tata, Jessica Lo, Mirella A. Fernandez, Annie-Lori Joseph, Jesse Matsubara, Julie Goldberg, Thuy-Tien D. Nguyen, Noa Sasson, Justine Lely, Bryan Smith, Kelly A. King, Jennifer Chisholm, Julie Christensen, M. Teresa Magone, Chantal Cousineau-Krieger, Rakibul Hafiz, Amritha Nayak, Okan Irfanoglu, Sanaz Attaripour, Chen Lai and Wendy B. Smith, 18 March 2024, JAMA.DOI: 10.1001/ jama.2024.2413.