May 8, 2024

A Better Way To Separate Gases: New Kind of Membrane Works With 1/10 the Energy and Emissions

By David L. Chandler, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
April 14, 2022

Gas separation is a extensive and important industrial process whose usages include eliminating pollutants and undesired compounds from natural gas or biogas, separating oxygen and nitrogen from air for medical and industrial purposes, separating carbon dioxide from other gases for carbon capture, and producing hydrogen for usage as a carbon-free transportation fuel. The brand-new type of polymers, established over the last a number of years by the Xia lab, are referred to as ladder polymers since they are formed from double strands connected by rung-like bonds, and these linkages provide a high degree of rigidity and stability to the polymer product. To use the CANAL polymers as selective membranes, the partnership made usage of Xias proficiency in polymers and Smiths expertise in membrane research. Remarkably, they discovered that adding additional kinks to their initial CANAL polymers substantially enhanced the mechanical robustness of their membranes and increased their selectivity for molecules of similar sizes, such as oxygen and nitrogen gases, without losing permeability of the more permeable gas. The combination of high selectivity and high permeability makes these products outshine all other polymer products in lots of gas separations, the scientists state.

The findings were reported on March 24, 2022, in the journal Science, in a paper by Yan Xia, an associate teacher of chemistry at Stanford; Zachary Smith, an assistant professor of chemical engineering at MIT; Ingo Pinnau, a professor at King Abdullah University of Science and Technology, and five others.
Gas separation is a widespread and crucial industrial procedure whose uses consist of eliminating impurities and unwanted substances from gas or biogas, separating oxygen and nitrogen from air for medical and industrial purposes, separating co2 from other gases for carbon capture, and producing hydrogen for usage as a carbon-free transportation fuel. The brand-new ladder polymer membranes reveal pledge for significantly improving the performance of such separation processes. For example, separating carbon dioxide from methane, these brand-new membranes have five times the selectivity and 100 times the permeability of existing cellulosic membranes for that purpose. Similarly, they are 100 times more permeable and three times as selective for separating hydrogen gas from methane.
The new type of polymers, established over the last numerous years by the Xia lab, are described as ladder polymers due to the fact that they are formed from double hairs linked by rung-like bonds, and these linkages supply a high degree of rigidity and stability to the polymer material. These ladder polymers are synthesized through an effective and selective chemistry the Xia lab established called CANAL, an acronym for catalytic arene-norbornene annulation, which stitches readily offered chemicals into ladder structures with hundreds and even thousands of rungs. The polymers are synthesized in a service, where they form rigid and kinked ribbon-like strands that can quickly be made into a thin sheet with sub-nanometer-scale pores by utilizing industrially readily available polymer casting procedures. The sizes of the resulting pores can be tuned through the choice of the specific hydrocarbon starting substances. “This chemistry and option of chemical structure blocks enabled us to make really rigid ladder polymers with different setups,” Xia says.
To use the CANAL polymers as selective membranes, the collaboration utilized Xias know-how in polymers and Smiths specialization in membrane research. Holden Lai, a former Stanford doctoral trainee, carried out much of the advancement and expedition of how their structures effect gas permeation residential or commercial properties. “It took us 8 years from developing the brand-new chemistry to finding the best polymer structures that bestow the high separation performance,” Xia says.
The Xia laboratory invested the past numerous years differing the structures of CANAL polymers to comprehend how their structures impact their separation efficiency. Remarkably, they found that adding extra kinks to their original CANAL polymers substantially improved the mechanical robustness of their membranes and improved their selectivity for particles of similar sizes, such as oxygen and nitrogen gases, without losing permeability of the more permeable gas. The selectivity really improves as the material ages. The combination of high selectivity and high permeability makes these products surpass all other polymer products in many gas separations, the researchers state.
Today, 15 percent of international energy usage enters into chemical separations, and these separation procedures are “often based upon century-old innovations,” Smith states. “They work well, however they have an enormous carbon footprint and consume massive amounts of energy. The crucial obstacle today is attempting to change these nonsustainable procedures.” Many of these processes need high temperatures for boiling and reboiling solutions, and these frequently are the hardest procedures to electrify, he includes.
For the separation of oxygen and nitrogen from air, the two particles just vary in size by about 0.18 angstroms (ten-billionths of a meter), he states. To make a filter efficient in separating them effectively “is extremely tough to do without decreasing throughput.” The new ladder polymers, when produced into membranes produce tiny pores that achieve high selectivity, he states. In many cases, 10 oxygen particles penetrate for every nitrogen, regardless of the razor-thin screen required to access this type of size selectivity. These new membrane products have “the greatest mix of permeability and selectivity of all understood polymeric materials for numerous applications,” Smith says.
” Because CANAL polymers are ductile and strong, and since they are soluble in specific solvents, they could be scaled for industrial implementation within a couple of years,” he includes. An MIT spinoff business called Osmoses, led by authors of this study, recently won the MIT $100K entrepreneurship competitors and has actually been partially funded by The Engine to advertise the innovation.
There are a range of potential applications for these materials in the chemical processing market, Smith states, including the separation of carbon dioxide from other gas mixtures as a kind of emissions decrease. Another possibility is the filtration of biogas fuel made from farming waste products in order to supply carbon-free transport fuel. Hydrogen separation for producing a chemical or a fuel feedstock, might likewise be performed effectively, helping with the transition to a hydrogen-based economy.
The close-knit group of scientists is continuing to refine the process to facilitate the advancement from lab to industrial scale, and to better comprehend the details on how the macromolecular structures and packaging lead to the ultrahigh selectivity. Smith says he expects this platform technology to play a role in several decarbonization pathways, starting with hydrogen separation and carbon capture, because there is such a pressing need for these innovations in order to transition to a carbon-free economy.
” These are remarkable new structures that have impressive gas separation efficiency,” says Ryan Lively, an associate teacher of chemical and biomolecular engineering at Georgia Tech, who was not involved in this work. “Importantly, this efficiency is enhanced during membrane aging and when the membranes are challenged with concentrated gas mixes. … If they can scale these products and make membrane modules, there is significant possible practical impact.”
Reference: “Hydrocarbon ladder polymers with ultrahigh permselectivity for membrane gas separations” by Holden W. H. Lai, Francesco M. Benedetti, Jun Myun Ahn, Ashley M. Robinson, Yingge Wang, Ingo Pinnau, Zachary P. Smith and Yan Xia, 24 March 2022, Science.DOI: 10.1126/ science.abl7163.
The research team likewise included Jun Myun Ahn and Ashley Robinson at Stanford, Francesco Benedetti at MIT, now the primary executive officer at Osmoses, and Yingge Wang at King Abdullah University of Science and Technology in Saudi Arabia. The work was supported by the Stanford Natural Gas Initiative, the Sloan Research Fellowship, the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Basic Energy Sciences, and the National Science Foundation.

A brand-new membrane material, visualized here, could make purification of gases considerably more efficient, possibly assisting to minimize carbon emissions. Credit: Courtesy of the researchers
A brand-new membrane product could make purification of gases considerably more effective, possibly helping to reduce carbon emissions.
Industrial procedures for chemical separations, including gas purification and the production of oxygen and nitrogen for commercial or medical uses, are collectively accountable for about 15 percent of the worlds energy usage. They also contribute a corresponding amount to the worlds greenhouse gas emissions. Now, scientists at MIT and Stanford University have actually developed a new kind of membrane for performing these separation processes with approximately 1/10 the energy use and emissions.
Using membranes for separation of chemicals is understood to be much more effective than procedures such as distillation or absorption, however there has always been a tradeoff between permeability– how quick gases can penetrate through the product– and selectivity– the ability to let the wanted molecules travel through while obstructing all others. The brand-new household of membrane products, based on “hydrocarbon ladder” polymers, gets rid of that tradeoff, providing both high permeability and very great selectivity, the researchers state.